Skip to content
Gold 24K / tola368,504Dollar (market)276.46Dollar open market280.05Petrol / litre323
zaviya
Trending#1Pakistan#2Punjab#3Lahore#4Islamabad#5Sindh#6Karachi#7Shehbaz Sharif#8Gold rate#9Namaz timings#10Dollar rate#11Baby names#12Petrol price
Breaking

New provinces in Pakistan debate sharpens after Naqvi plan

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi's referendum proposal on new provinces in Pakistan drew opposition from PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto, while MQM and Mustafa Kamal backed the idea.

Zaviya Desk

· 4 min read

WhatsApp
Zaviya (AI-generated image)

The debate over new provinces in Pakistan has sharpened after Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi proposed a referendum on the question, and PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto rejected the idea. Naqvi made the proposal on Thursday, 12 November, in Islamabad, saying surveys show that most people support new provinces. On Tuesday, 17 November, Bilawal responded in Karachi, saying the Constitution already sets out a clear method for creating provinces and that an unconstitutional route cannot be backed.

Bilawal also said parliament has made no formal progress on the issue, and the federal cabinet has neither discussed nor decided it. He said the topic had been raised 'by force' for several months.

Naqvi's proposal and where the debate began

Get Zaviya on WhatsApp →

Naqvi opened the current discussion on 30 July, when he said the system the country operates under had collapsed and suggested that new provinces could help solve its problems. On 12 November he moved from that suggestion to a specific step, proposing a referendum, which is a direct vote in which citizens answer a set question, usually with a yes or no.

He said that if people rejected new provinces, he would fully accept the result, and that if they backed them, the path to creating them should be cleared. He argued that letting the public decide was the best way to end the debate. The surveys he cited have not been independently confirmed.

Bilawal's objection and the reactions that followed

Bilawal said he did not know what Naqvi intended. He asked why the PPP and other political forces had not been taken into confidence if the interior minister was serious about the plan. He warned that a forced division of Sindh could have serious consequences, and urged Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to have control over his own minister.

Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal said new provinces were indispensable to saving Pakistan, and that if a single drop of blood were shed, responsibility would lie with Bilawal. Kamal said he was saddened by Bilawal's remark that blood would flow in Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas and Sukkur, areas he described as long home to Muhajir communities. He asked why the PPP should worry about ten provinces in Sindh if its own record was good.

The MQM Pakistan spokesperson told Bilawal to stop what he called blackmailing the state and government. The spokesperson asked why, if new provinces were created across the country, bloodshed would be expected only in Karachi and urban Sindh. The party said creating new provinces is a constitutional requirement, and that most people in urban Sindh support them nationwide.

Not everyone agrees on the next step. Punjab Assembly Speaker Malik Muhammad Ahmad Khan said it was too early to comment on a referendum on provinces, and questioned whether any assembly had asked for one. He added that three parties had tried to reach an agreement through talks but had not succeeded.

Timeline: what has happened so far

  • 30 July: Mohsin Naqvi said the system had collapsed and suggested new provinces as a way to address the country's problems.
  • Thursday, 12 November: Naqvi proposed a referendum on new provinces in Islamabad.
  • Tuesday, 17 November: Bilawal Bhutto opposed the referendum idea in Karachi and warned against a forced division of Sindh.

Aasan alfaaz mein

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi ne naye soobon ke liye referendum ki tajweez di hai, jabke PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto ne is ki mukhalifat ki hai aur kaha hai ke aaeeni tareeqa maujood hai. MQM aur federal health minister Mustafa Kamal naye soobon ke haq mein hain, jabke Punjab Assembly ke speaker ne kaha hai ke referendum par abhi kuch kehna qabl az waqt hai. Abhi tak parliament aur cabinet mein koi faisla nahi hua, is liye aam logon ki rozmarra zindagi par fori tabdeeli nahi aayi. Lekin Sindh mein is bahs par nazar rakhna zaroori hai.

Questions readers ask

FAQ

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi ne naye soobon ke liye referendum ki tajweez di hai. Bilawal Bhutto ne is tajweez ki mukhalifat ki aur kaha ke aaeeni tareeqa maujood hai.
Share this story
WhatsApp
Web stories →

Add Zaviya as a preferred source on Google

Google par Zaviya ko apna pasandeeda source banayein.

Add on Google
Get Pakistan’s key news daily: follow usXFacebookInstagramLinkedInYouTubeWhatsApp

Morning briefing

Top Pakistan stories in your inbox.

Read next

More from Pakistan

See all

More from 20 November 2026

Share on WhatsApp