The Supreme Court of Pakistan has ruled that a decree validated by an Abu Dhabi court cannot be enforced directly in Pakistan under Section 44A of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), the law that deals with foreign court decrees. The Supreme Court decision came in a 2-1 majority judgment that accepted an appeal filed by a private company. The court set aside the orders of the Lahore High Court and a subordinate court, which had been handling the enforcement.
What the court decided
The case examined the legal standing of the federal courts of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the local courts of Abu Dhabi, one of the emirates. The majority said the Abu Dhabi local appeal court could not be treated as the UAE federal appeal court. It added that moving local judicial authority to federal courts requires a specific federal law.
On the facts of the case, the majority held that the disputed decree could not be enforced directly in Pakistan under Section 44A. It also said the Lahore execution court did not have the power to enforce that decree under the same section. The reports of the ruling describe it as an important judgment on how foreign decrees are handled in Pakistan.
Split bench and dissent
Justice Munib Akhtar and Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui agreed to accept the company's appeal, while Justice Irfan Saadat Khan gave a dissenting view. Because the two-judge bench could not agree, the matter was referred to a third judge as referee. Justice Siddiqui, acting as the referee judge, agreed with the opinion of Justice Akhtar.
Justice Khan argued that the judgment of the first court had merged into the judgment of the appellate court. In his view, the decree being enforced should be treated as an appellate court decree. He also noted that the UAE is recognised as a territory with reciprocal enforcement arrangements, and said an appellate decree from the UAE could be enforced in Pakistan.
Aasan alfaaz mein
Supreme Court ne 2-1 ke faisle mein kaha hai ke Abu Dhabi ki ek decree Section 44A ke tehat Pakistan mein seedha nafiz nahi ho sakti. Adalat ne ek nijī company ki appeal manzoor ki aur Lahore High Court aur neechi adalat ke hukam set aside kar diye. Justice Irfan Saadat Khan ne is faisle se ikhtilaaf kiya. Aam shehri ke liye iska matlab yeh hai ke bahar ki adalati decree ka Pakistan mein nafiz hona qanooni rasta par munhasir hai.











