Information Minister Atta Tarar's apology to the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) came on Friday, when he appeared before the electoral body in person and tendered an unconditional apology over an alleged violation of the ECP's code of conduct. The case concerns the NA-77 Gujranwala seat, a National Assembly constituency where a by-election, a poll held to fill a single vacant seat, took place on 8 November. After hearing the matter, the three-member bench reserved its verdict, so the commission has not yet ruled on it.
The ECP's code of conduct bars government functionaries from visiting any electoral constituency where an election has been announced and the related programme has been notified by the commission. Ahead of the NA-77 by-election, the ECP took notice of media reports suggesting that the information minister had landed in the constituency by helicopter and had taken part in a gathering there. The commission then summoned Tarar in his personal capacity over the alleged violation. In a public statement at the time, the ECP said the result of the by-election could be withheld until the matter was decided.
What the minister and his counsel told the bench
Tarar appeared with his counsel, Advocate Sajeed Swati. The counsel told the bench that the minister's visit to Gujranwala was personal and had nothing to do with the by-poll, adding that Tarar had gone there on the invitation of an office-bearer of the District Bar Association. "This visit was personal, not political," Swati said.
Chief Election Commissioner Sikandar Sultan Raja, who headed the bench, said that accepting an invitation explained the visit, but that Tarar was also a federal minister and that this carried certain implications. The bench, which also includes Nisar Ahmed Durrani and Shah Muhammad Jatoi, then reserved its verdict. Speaking to reporters after the hearing, Tarar said he had apologised to the ECP unconditionally. He added, "We hold the Election Commission in high esteem."
Earlier hearings and the NA-77 result
Tarar did not appear before the bench at the previous hearing on 12 November. At that hearing, CEC Raja warned that failing to honour the commission's directives could have "potentially grim consequences." The next day, the ECP notified Raashid Bashir Virk of the PML-N as the returned candidate for NA-77, which is the official declaration of the winner.
The seat had fallen vacant after the death of PML-N's Mahmood Bashir Virk, Raashid's father, on 11 September. Friday's hearing was held at Tarar's request to change the date that had been fixed for 1 December. Ahead of the hearing, the commission's position was that the by-poll result could still be held back pending the outcome.
Timeline: what has happened so far
- 11 September: PML-N's Mahmood Bashir Virk dies, leaving the NA-77 seat vacant.
- 7 November: A day before the by-election, the ECP takes notice of media reports about the minister's visit.
- 8 November: The by-election is held on the NA-77 Gujranwala seat.
- 12 November: Tarar does not appear at the hearing, and CEC Raja warns of grim consequences.
- 13 November: The ECP notifies Raashid Bashir Virk as the returned candidate.
- Friday, at a hearing held after Tarar's request to move the 1 December date: Tarar apologises unconditionally, and the bench reserves its verdict.
Aasan alfaaz mein
Information Minister Atta Tarar ne Friday ko Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) ke samne bina kisi shart ke maafi mangi. Yeh maamla NA-77 Gujranwala ke by-election ke dauran ECP ke code of conduct ki kathit khilaf-warzi se mutaliq hai. Bench ne faisla mehfooz kar liya hai, is liye abhi tak koi faisla nahi aaya. Aam shehri ke liye matlab yeh hai ke wazir bhi election ke qawaneen par utni hi sakhti se amal karen, aur is par ECP ka faisla dekhna hoga.











