Skip to content
Gold 24K / tola402,115Dollar (market)276.56Dollar open market279.5Petrol / litre330
zaviya
Trending#1Khyber Pakhtunkhwa#2Lahore#3Islamabad#4Pakistan#5Higher Education Commission#6Balochistan#7Faisal Karim Kundi#8Gold rate#9Namaz timings#10Dollar rate#11Baby names#12Petrol price
Breaking

FCC ruling on PHC jurisdiction: MPO cases remain barred

The FCC ruling on PHC jurisdiction lets the Peshawar High Court hear most Article 199 petitions again, while governor's rule and MPO detention cases remain restricted.

Zaviya Desk

· 3 min read

WhatsApp
Photo: Muhammad Imran Saeed / CC BY 2.5 / Wikimedia Commons

The FCC ruling on PHC jurisdiction, issued on Monday by the Federal Constitutional Court, means the Peshawar High Court, or PHC, may again hear most petitions under Article 199, the constitutional provision that lets high courts review official actions and enforce fundamental rights. Two areas remain excluded: cases concerning governor's rule or the state of emergency in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP), and arrests made under the Maintenance of Public Order (MPO) Ordinance. The two-member bench was headed by Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan.

What the bench said

The bench explained that its November 5 order was meant only for matters linked to governor's rule and MPO arrests. Other Article 199 cases could therefore continue at the PHC. Justice Aamer Farooq, who sat on the bench, pointed to Article 245 and observed that a plain reading of it would seem to bar all such petitions. He cautioned, however, that such a literal approach would effectively freeze the courts.

Get Zaviya on WhatsApp →

The court also let the Peshawar Bar Council join the case, calling the emergency an important constitutional matter that needed the input of bar councils. Barrister Gohar Ali Khan, who leads PTI, told the bench that the order had disrupted proceedings at the PHC and stalled lawyers' professional work. He sought relief for political workers and leaders held under Section 3 of the MPO Ordinance, arguing that they had no effective remedy. In a post on X after the hearing, he said the order had also touched petitions about the chief minister, the provincial assembly speaker and other lawmakers.

Pending issues and what comes next

The FCC ruling on PHC jurisdiction leaves several questions open. The Khyber Pakhtunkhwa advocate general told the court that a review board would be set up once the three-month period ends, and cases of people held beyond that period could then be referred to it. Gohar said no review board had yet been constituted, and he also raised the position of people held at police lines. Several miscellaneous applications have been filed at the Peshawar registry and will be considered once they reach the bench, the Chief Justice said, and the court adjourned the matter indefinitely.

Timeline: what has happened so far

  • October 11: President Asif Ali Zardari approved emergency measures and governor's rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa after the federal government recommended them, and armed forces were brought in under Article 245.
  • October 12: Article 199 petitions filed from this date onward were later covered by the FCC's halt.
  • October 14: PTI challenged the emergency and governor's rule before the PHC, seeking to have the elected provincial government restored.
  • November 5: The FCC stopped hearings on Article 199 cases from that date onward, citing Article 245, and the PHC's administrative committee suspended the affected hearings.
  • Monday, the day of the latest hearing: The FCC clarified its November 5 order, let the Peshawar Bar Council join the case, and adjourned proceedings indefinitely.

Aasan alfaaz mein

FCC ne clear kiya hai ke Peshawar High Court ab Article 199 ke zyadatar petitions dobara sun sakti hai. Magar KP mein governor raj aur MPO ke tahat hiraasat walay mamlay abhi bhi is faisle se bahar hain. Iska matlab hai ke wakeelon aur aam logon ke liye adalati kaam dobara shuru ho sakta hai, lekin hiraasat mein rakhay gaye log abhi intezar mein hain.

Questions readers ask

FAQ

Yes, for most of them. The FCC said the Peshawar High Court can hear Article 199 petitions other than those concerning governor's rule or the state of emergency in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and arrests under the MPO Ordinance.

Share this story
WhatsApp
Web stories →

Add Zaviya as a preferred source on Google

Google par Zaviya ko apna pasandeeda source banayein.

Add on Google
Get Pakistan’s key news daily: follow usXFacebookInstagramLinkedInYouTubeWhatsApp

Morning briefing

Top Pakistan stories in your inbox.

Read next

More from Pakistan

See all

More from 17 November 2026

Share on WhatsApp