The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), Pakistan's tax authority, has proposed a set of rules that would let income tax appeals be decided without the parties meeting the deciding officer in person. The plan, set out in a draft notification, would create faceless appeals and keep the identity of the commissioner handling each case hidden from the taxpayer. The draft is not final and will not take effect until it is formally notified.
Income tax disputes arise when a taxpayer contests an assessment or order issued by tax officials, and appeals are the usual route for challenging that decision.
How faceless appeals would work
The draft notification, issued on November 18, proposes adding a chapter titled Faceless Appeals to the Income Tax Rules, 2002. An Appeals Wing, made up of appellate units headed by Commissioners (Appeals), would handle eligible cases through the FBR's e-portal. The wing would sit under the Member (Legal) of Inland Revenue but would keep its independence in deciding appeals.
Cases would be assigned at random by an automated system. The unit and the commissioner handling a case would stay unnamed through to the final order. Taxpayers would upload their evidence and arguments through the portal, and hearings could take place over video link or on secure digital platforms. Appellants could also ask for a ruling based only on their written submissions.
Officers, signatures and portal delays
Officers who had a role in auditing, assessing, checking the quality of, or issuing the original order on a case would not be allowed to decide its appeal. Final orders would bear a Digital Identification Number instead of a commissioner's name or signature. If a portal failure is confirmed, the draft says it could justify a delay in filing.
Pending appeals would stay with the current commissioners unless the Board moves them. The option to go straight to the Appellate Tribunal under Section 127 would not change. Anyone affected has three days from the Gazette publication of the draft to lodge objections or suggestions, and the framework will not take effect until it is finally notified.
Aasan alfaaz mein
FBR ne income tax appeals ko online karne ka draft pesh kiya hai. Is tajweez ke tehat appeal ka faisla karne wale afsar ka naam zahir nahi hoga aur sunwai video ke zariye ho sakti hai. Yeh abhi final nahi hai, is liye 3 din ke andar aitraz ya suggestions bheji ja sakti hain. Aam taxpayer ke liye iska matlab hai ke case dakhil karne ke liye daftar jaane ki zaroorat kam ho sakti hai.











