A new report from the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ), released on Wednesday, concludes that the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments have produced “systemic judicial capture” in Pakistan. Put simply, the courts can no longer act as an independent check on the state, the report says. The ICJ traces this change to amendments made to the constitution, rather than to the removal of individual judges. It calls on the government to conduct a broad review of both amendments.
The 26th Amendment, approved in October 2024, created constitutional benches separate from the Supreme Court. Their members were chosen by a reconstituted Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP), the body that appoints judges, in which judges had lost their majority.
The 27th Amendment followed barely a year later. It turned those benches into a separate Federal Constitutional Court, and it also altered the military chain of command and gave immunities to government officials. Two of the Supreme Court’s most senior judges resigned in protest on the day the 27th Amendment became law.
What the report found
The report examined the institutional framework that governs the higher courts after the two amendments. It concluded that the judiciary no longer has the institutional guarantees of independence that international law expects. The authors stressed that the weakening came through constitutional change rather than the open removal of judges.
The report also accepts that the Supreme Court had moved into the roles of Parliament and other institutions. Its objection is that Parliament, when it passed the two amendments, did not correct those problems in a way that protected judicial independence. According to the ICJ, the ruling coalition used public anger over the working of the courts to bring the judiciary under its control, leaving the highest courts unable to check the executive or Parliament.
Government’s argument and next steps
The government said the amendments were meant to curb judicial overreach, cut the backlog of cases, address what it described as the politicisation of the apex court’s original jurisdiction, and give Parliament a say in judicial appointments similar to lawmakers in other democracies. The ICJ said these goals did not justify reshaping the court structure in a way that clearly clashes with Pakistan’s obligations under international law. It urged the government to begin a full review of the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments and of how they have been put into practice.
Because these are recommendations rather than a court ruling, what happens next depends on whether the government takes up that call and launches a review.
Timeline: what has happened so far
- October 2024: The 26th Amendment is approved, creating constitutional benches separate from the Supreme Court.
- About a year later: The 27th Amendment turns those benches into the Federal Constitutional Court and changes the military chain of command.
- The day the 27th Amendment became law: Two of the Supreme Court’s most senior judges resign in protest.
- Wednesday, as reported on 19 November 2026: The ICJ releases its report on judicial capture and urges a review of both amendments.
Aasan alfaaz mein
International Commission of Jurists (ICJ) ki report kehti hai ke 26th aur 27th Constitutional Amendments ne Pakistan ki adaalaton ki azadi ko kamzor kar diya hai. 26th Amendment ne Supreme Court se alag constitutional benches banaye, aur 27th Amendment ne in benches ko Federal Constitutional Court bana diya. Report ne hukoomat se in tabdeeliyon ka mukammal jaiza lene ki sifarish ki hai. Aam shehri ke liye iska matlab hai ke adaalati faislon aur judges ki azadi par bahas abhi jari rahegi.











