The Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan (FCCP) has ruled that pay upgradation is neither automatic nor a right that government employees can enforce in court. The court held that judges cannot order a pay scale change where there is no relevant policy or legal basis. It dismissed petitions filed by employees of the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) who had sought higher pay scales, and it upheld the decision of the Islamabad High Court.
What the court said
Justice Ali Baqar Najafi wrote the five-page judgment. He observed that policy-making falls within the domain of the executive, meaning the government's administrative arm. Courts, the judgment said, should not interfere in administrative policy matters unless a fundamental right has been violated or an action is unlawful or unconstitutional.
Why the FIA comparison failed
The FIA works under the Federal Investigation Agency Act, 1974. The court found that comparing the grades of employees in different government departments is not legally justified. For that reason, FIA staff cannot claim a legal right to an upgrade simply because employees of other departments receive better pay or benefits.
What comes next
Any upgrade would need to come from a policy decision or a legal basis, the court made clear, because judicial intervention is not warranted without one. The ruling therefore keeps pay upgrade decisions with the government's policy process rather than with the courts.
Aasan alfaaz mein
Federal Constitutional Court ne faisla diya hai ke sarkari mulazimon ka pay upgradation khud bakhud nahi hota aur adalat isay hukm nahi de sakti jab tak koi policy ya qanooni bunyad na ho. FIA ke mulazimon ki darkhwastein khaarij ho gayi hain. Aam logon ke liye iska matlab hai ke tankhwah mein izafa policy ke tehat hi ho sakta hai, adalat ke hukm se nahi.











