Defence Minister Khawaja Asif of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) has answered Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, chairperson of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), after a sharp speech in which Bilawal questioned the government's decisions. In a post on X on Wednesday, Asif wrote that 'he who claims equity must come with clean hands', calling it a centuries-old maxim of equity. The exchange has deepened the public rift between the two parties, which are coalition partners in the government.
What Bilawal said
Bilawal's speech, delivered the previous day, covered several issues, including the creation of new provinces, constitutional changes and the treatment of the opposition. He referred to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi's suggestion of a referendum on new administrative units. He argued that in Pakistan's history referendums had always been used for undemocratic acts, never democratic ones.
Bilawal also said the governance system had not collapsed but had been 'made to collapse', which appeared to respond to Naqvi's July statement that the system had collapsed and needed a reset. He backed several opposition demands, including the release of former prime minister and Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) founder Imran Khan. He also questioned past decisions taken by the ruling coalition.
Asif's response
Asif began by addressing the 'system collapse' remark. He said no system can reset without public support, and that everyone connected to the system must also take stock of their responsibilities. He added that a debate on a system reset would surely take place in Parliament, and that public opinion should be weighed alongside the view of Parliament.
On accountability, Asif said holding politicians to account in Pakistan was nothing new and that no politician was exempt, which appeared to be a reply to Bilawal's support for Imran Khan's release. He then pointed to the PPP's 18 years in power in Sindh, saying the province had turned into a paradise and that the world admired Karachi. The remark appeared to be a jibe at the PPP, which is often criticised over the state of development in Sindh.
Asif also said the PPP had been a partner of the PML-N in running the government since 2022, adding that the party took the profit while the PML-N and Pakistan suffered the loss. He closed by asking whether Bilawal's own hands were clean and whether he had the right to lecture or threaten. He said the government's goal was to change people's lives so that ordinary citizens could live with dignity.
Coalition strain
The two sets of remarks show how far apart the coalition partners have become on provinces, accountability and the opposition. Bilawal framed the matter as one of how the system is run, while Asif framed it as a question of who has the standing to criticise. Bilawal Bhutto and Asif have not, in these remarks, moved toward a shared position, and the wrangling appeared to deepen after the exchange.
Aasan alfaaz mein
Pakistan Peoples Party ke chairperson Bilawal Bhutto Zardari ki taqreer par hukmran PML-N ke Khawaja Asif ne X par jawab diya hai. Unhon ne kaha ke jo insaaf ki baat karta hai us ke haath saaf hone chahiye. Bilawal ne nayi provinces aur opposition ke mamlay par tanqeed ki thi. Aam shehri ke liye iska matlab yeh hai ke hukmran itehadiyon ke andar ikhtilaaf khul kar samne aa raha hai.











